Why Oval for Retrofit and Renovation
Why Oval for retrofit and renovations?
Oval low-profile fire extinguishers provide compelling advantages when retrofitting fire extinguishers into an existing facility or when a facility is undergoing renovation. In many cases, Oval fire extinguishers are the only way to achieve compliance with requirements for accessibility.
In an existing facility, the simplest and easiest way to install a fire extinguisher is simply to mount the extinguisher on the wall. This is particularly true if the facility is occupied and in continuous use. In these situations, an Oval low-profile fire extinguisher will comply with accessibility requirements. A conventional fire extinguisher will not.
However, simply mounting a fire extinguisher on a wall will not always be a desirable solution. This may be because surface mounted fire extinguishers:
• Create obstacles and risks of collision.
• Can be bumped or pushed and possibly dislodged from the wall hook.
• Invite vandalism.
• Are unsightly and visually unappealing.
To avoid these problems, we always recommend installing a fire extinguisher in a cabinet.
Surface mounted cabinets are the simplest and easiest to use for retrofit or renovation. Oval offers surface mounted cabinets that are less than 4” (102mm) deep. These cabinets provide compliance with accessibility requirements. Surface mounted cabinets for conventional fire extinguishers do not, since they project more than 4” (102mm) from the wall.
Unfortunately, surface mounted cabinets present some of the same issues as surface mounted fire extinguishers (collision hazards, unattractive appearance, etc.). Most significantly, when used with a conventional fire extinguisher, the cabinet will project more than 4” (102mm) from the wall surface and not provide accessibility compliance.
The only alternative to surface mounting on the wall is to inset a cabinet partially or fully into the wall. This requires a significant amount of construction work, typically involving:
1. Screening off or possibly vacating the area entirely.
2. Cutting an opening in the wall. This can create significant dust and noise.
3. Installing blocking in the wall to support the weight of the cabinet and fire extinguisher.
4. Installing the cabinet in the wall.
5. Patching the wall around the cabinet.
6. Taping, sanding and painting the wall.
The real problem with doing all of this is that, when retrofitting or renovating, the wall is usually preexisting. The wall was probably not built with adequate depth to allow for recessing the cabinet fully into the wall. The only choice is then a semi-recessed cabinet. Even after incurring the disruption, time and expense of installing a cabinet, the cabinet will still project out from the wall, reducing the usable corridor width, creating collision hazards and presenting an unattractive appearance.
Oval low-profile fire extinguishers can be fully recessed into 3-5/8” (92mm) partition walls. They will therefore usually be the best – and possibly the only – choice for full recessing of the fire extinguishers.
Regardless of which mounting option is selected, Oval low-profile extinguishers provide compelling advantages. These advantages are highlighted below:
Option 1: Surface Mounting
![]() |
![]() |
|||
Low-Profile Fire Extinguisher | Conventional Fire Extinguisher | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Projection from Wall | 3″ (76mm) or 3-1/2″ (89mm) maximum, depending on model | At least 5″ (127mm) | ||
Accessibility | Meets all ADA and code requirements for accessibility | Does NOT meet accessibility requirements | ||
Corridor/Aisle Width | Minimizes loss of usable corridor and aisle width | Reduces usable corridor and aisle width by 5″ (127mm) or more | ||
Collision Hazard | Can create an obstacle and collision hazard in corridors and aisles (though less than conventional extinguishers) | Creates an obstacle and collision hazard in corridors and aisles | ||
Mounting | Uses swivel-type button hook that holds extinguisher securely on wall, even if bumped or pushed | Uses unreliable and potentially dangerous wall hook. Extinguisher can fall off wall if bumped. | ||
Appearance | Visually unappealing. Appearance is usually not acceptable in offices, healthcare facilities, hotels and public spaces. | Visually unappealing | ||
Ease of Installation | Fastest and easiest installation method | Fastest and easiest installation method | ||
Total Installed Cost | Lowest cost option for retrofitting a fire extinguisher. | Lowest cost option for retrofitting a fire extinguisher. |
Option 2: Surface Mounted Cabinet with Fire Extinguisher Inside
![]() |
![]() |
|||
Low-Profile Fire Extinguisher | Conventional Fire Extinguisher | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Projection from Wall | 4″ (102mm) maximum | At least 6″ (152mm) | ||
Accessibility | Meets all ADA and code requirements for accessibility | Does NOT meet accessibility requirements | ||
Corridor/Aisle Width | Minimizes loss of usable corridor and aisle width | Reduces usable corridor and aisle width by 6″ or more | ||
Collision Hazard | Can create an obstacle and collision hazard in corridors and aisles (though less than conventional extinguishers) | Creates an obstacle and collision hazard in corridors and aisles | ||
Appearance | Better than Option 1 but still visually unappealing. Appearance is usually not acceptable in offices, healthcare facilities, hotels and public spaces. | Better than Option 1 but still visually unappealing. | ||
Ease of Installation | Relatively fast and easy installation method | Relatively fast and easy installation method | ||
Total Installed Cost | More expensive than Option 1 | More expensive than Option 1 |
Option 3: Semi-Recessed Cabinet with Fire Extinguisher Inside
![]() |
![]() |
|||
Low-Profile Fire Extinguisher | Conventional Fire Extinguisher | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Cabinets for Oval fire extinguishers can be fully recessed into an existing 3-5/8″ (92mm) partition wall. A semi-recessed cabinet is therefore never required. This installation option is irrelevant with low-profile fire extinguishers. | Due to the size of conventional fire extinguishers, typical partition walls do not have sufficient depth to accommodate a fire extinguisher cabinet. Since complete rebuilding of walls is generally not possible in retrofit applications, the cabinet must partially project out from the wall. Use of a semi-recessed cabinet may therefore be the only way to achieve accessibility compliance. These cabinets are always a “make do” compromise since they are unsightly, create collision hazards, waste floor space and are expensive. |
Option 4: Recessed Cabinet with Fire Extinguisher Inside
![]() |
![]() |
|||
Low-Profile Fire Extinguisher | Conventional Fire Extinguisher | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Design Challenge | Due to the reduced depth of low-profile fire extinguishers, cabinets can be fully recessed into an exisitng 3-5/8″ (92mm) partition wall. | Requires that wall have sufficient depth to accommodate a cabinet that is at least 6″ (152mm) deep. Therefore this is usually not a viable option for retrofit applications. | ||
Fire Rating | Can use fire-rated cabinet to maintain 2 hour fire rating of wall | |||
Accessibility | Meets all ADA and code requirements for accessibility | |||
Corridor/Aisle Width | No reduction in usable corridor and aisle width | |||
Collision Hazard | Eliminates obstacles and collision hazards in corridors and aisles | |||
Appearance | Best appearance. Widely used in offices, healthcare facilities, hotels and public spaces. | |||
Ease of Installation | As described above, there is usually significant disruption, time and expense required for installation. | |||
Total Installed Cost | Highest installed cost of four options. |